Case Details
I. Case Information
Case category: Litigation representation / criminal defense
Stage: Investigation, including review for approval of arrest
Defense counsel: Peng Xin and Pan Meiyu
Law firm: Guangdong FANA Chuanqiong Law Firm
Suspected offenses: Sham litigation and fraudulent bankruptcy
Outcome: Three decisions not to approve arrest, release from custody on bail pending trial, and ultimate dismissal of the investigation without criminal liability
II. Case Background
In October 2015, Liu joined a real-estate investment company as general manager to address its business difficulties. After assessing the company, he concluded that its accumulated problems could not be resolved and contacted several creditors to seek bankruptcy reorganization before a municipal intermediate people’s court. In May 2017, following an audit showing approximately RMB 790 million in assets and nearly RMB 1.1 billion in liabilities, the court accepted the case and the company entered bankruptcy proceedings.
During the claims-filing period, Liu was responsible for reviewing and confirming claims. In February 2019, he discovered that Huang’s RMB 25 million claim overlapped with claims filed by Tang and four other creditors. He arranged for documents to be retrieved and compared, then notified the relevant creditors to withdraw duplicate claims. In April 2019, the administrator confirmed that the RMB 25 million duplicate claim had been deducted. The case also involved complex issues concerning RMB 10 million in claims and rights to three shops asserted by shareholder Zeng and his family, as well as RMB 60 million in private lending.
On July 8, 2019, police placed Liu in criminal detention on suspicion of sham litigation. Three arrest-review rounds followed. On August 14, 2019, the procuratorate declined to approve the first arrest request, but police changed the measure that day to residential surveillance at a designated location, transferring him directly from the detention center. On September 25, 2019, police submitted a second arrest request on the same matter; it was again denied. On October 28, 2019, police submitted a third request, changing the alleged offense to fraudulent bankruptcy. The procuratorate again declined to approve arrest. On the day of that third decision, police released Liu from custody and placed him on bail pending trial. The investigation was ultimately dismissed, and he was not held criminally responsible.
III. Defense Work and Professional Contribution
1. Prompt Advocacy During the Critical Early Investigation Period
Attorneys Peng Xin and Pan Meiyu acted promptly after Liu’s detention, visiting him repeatedly before arrest review to verify the facts. During the first review, they submitted Legal Opinions Opposing Approval of Arrest explaining why sham litigation was not established. They also submitted an Opinion Requesting Release Without Criminal Liability to police, seeking dismissal of the investigation and release.
2. Challenging the Elements: Neither the Conduct nor Criminal Intent Was Established
Counsel separately addressed the elements of sham litigation and fraudulent bankruptcy:
Performance of duties without fabricated facts: Reconfirming claims and replacing loan documents fell within Liu’s duties as general manager. He cross-checked company bank records against creditors’ transfer receipts, and the debts he confirmed were supported by genuine documents. Counsel argued that he had not fabricated debts from nothing.
No criminal intent: Liu could not know whether original debt documents had been falsified before he joined. His proactive request that creditors withdraw duplicate claims demonstrated that he did not support false filings. The existence of duplicate claims alone could not establish that he knowingly participated.
Genuine insolvency: The court-commissioned audit confirmed liabilities of nearly RMB 1.1 billion against RMB 790 million in assets. The bankruptcy was genuine. A duplicate RMB 25 million claim was insufficient to cause insolvency and, counsel argued, did not satisfy the relevant requirement of assuming fictitious debts for fraudulent bankruptcy.
No required harmful consequence: Claims remained under the administrator’s review; the court had not finally confirmed them or approved a distribution plan. The duplicate claims had already been withdrawn and deducted. Counsel argued that the required interference with judicial order or serious infringement of others’ rights had not occurred.
3. Procedural Advocacy Against Disguised Detention and Repeated Arrest Requests
After the first refusal to approve arrest, police used residential surveillance at a designated location instead of bail and subsequently made further arrest requests. The source describes this as twice changing the alleged offense. Counsel continued visiting Liu and promptly submitted supplemental opinions addressing each new issue, including Zeng’s RMB 10 million claim and shop rights and the audit of RMB 60 million in loans. Counsel challenged speculative inferences of intent, disguised detention, and repeated arrest requests under changing allegations, urging the procuratorate to maintain its refusal and secure immediate release.
4. Comparable Cases and Restraint in the Use of Criminal Law
Counsel submitted judgments on fraudulent bankruptcy supporting the positions that genuine bankruptcy does not constitute that offense and that inflated debts insufficient to create a false appearance of insolvency, without serious actual harm, do not establish it. Counsel also invoked restraint in criminal-law intervention: where civil and commercial law can regulate the conduct, criminal law should be used cautiously, and a civil dispute should not be criminalized without substantive evidence of intentional collusion.
IV. Outcome
The case ended during investigation. Police requested approval of arrest three times, and the procuratorate declined all three requests, including the third based on fraudulent bankruptcy.
First request, sham litigation: Arrest was not approved; the client was transferred to residential surveillance at a designated location.
Second request, sham litigation: Arrest was again not approved.
Third request, fraudulent bankruptcy: Arrest was not approved for a third time.
Release: On the day of the third refusal, police released Liu from custody and changed the measure to bail pending trial.
Final result: The investigation was dismissed, and Liu was not held criminally responsible.
Three arrest requests and three refusals: despite repeated prosecutorial decisions not to approve arrest, investigators continued seeking arrest under changing allegations and used residential surveillance at a designated location in what the account describes as disguised detention. Sustained defense advocacy and prosecutorial scrutiny ultimately resulted in release, bail pending trial, and dismissal of the investigation.
V. Broader Significance
1. The Value of Early Investigation-Stage Advocacy
Approximately three and a half months elapsed between criminal detention and the third refusal to approve arrest, all during investigation. Frequent client contact and sustained written advocacy contributed to three refusals and eventual dismissal. The account presents arrest review as a particularly effective opportunity to protect a client’s interests.
2. Responding to Disguised Detention and Repeated Arrest Requests
The source criticizes the investigators’ use of designated-location surveillance after arrest was refused and their repeated arrest requests, described as involving two changes of offense. Counsel responded with targeted supplemental opinions, objections to disguised detention, and arguments about procedural abuse. This approach is presented as relevant to similar investigation-stage cases.
3. Distinguishing Civil Disputes from Criminal Offenses
Bankruptcy reorganization involves many parties and complex claims, making filing errors and duplicates possible. The defense used four questions to distinguish civil issues from sham litigation or fraudulent bankruptcy: whether the conduct performed job duties, whether the person knowingly acted unlawfully, whether the bankruptcy was genuine, and whether the required harm occurred. The approach sought to prevent liability based solely on outcomes and improper criminal intervention in economic disputes.
4. Restraint in Criminal-Law Intervention in Practice
The evidence did not establish intentional collusion or that Liu knowingly sought or accepted duplicate filings. The procuratorate maintained its refusal to approve arrest three times, contributing to eventual dismissal. The account presents this as an example of restrained criminal-law intervention and effective prosecutorial supervision of arrest decisions.
Frequently Asked Questions
How can the defense challenge wrongful detention during investigation?
During the period between criminal detention and arrest review, counsel can promptly meet the client, verify facts, and submit opinions opposing approval of arrest. Those opinions can address each element of the alleged offense, evidentiary gaps, absence of intent, and comparable cases. Here, all three arrest requests were denied and the investigation was ultimately dismissed.
What is residential surveillance at a designated location, and can it be misused?
It is a compulsory measure under the Criminal Procedure Law, described in the source as lasting no more than six months. Using it as disguised detention constitutes misuse. Counsel can continue lawful client meetings, submit legal opinions, and seek to ensure that authorities exercise their powers lawfully.
How do sham litigation and fraudulent bankruptcy differ?
The source describes sham litigation as bringing a civil action on fabricated facts that interferes with judicial order or seriously infringes others’ lawful rights. It describes fraudulent bankruptcy as concealing property, assuming fictitious debts, or otherwise transferring or disposing of assets to carry out a false bankruptcy that seriously harms creditors or others. It states that all three objective elements are necessary and that a genuine bankruptcy does not constitute fraudulent bankruptcy.
Have a similar case?
Contact Us