Case Details
1. Basic Case Information
1. Offense and Its Elements
The principal offense was contract fraud. Under Article 224 of the Criminal Law of the People’s Republic of China, the core elements involve an intent to unlawfully appropriate property and obtaining the other contracting party’s property by fabricating facts or concealing the truth in the formation or performance of a contract.
At the first trial and retrial, the courts found that the defendants, Pan, the legal representative, and Pan, the general manager, knew that the company, referred to here as the Foshan company, had substantial debts and lacked actual capacity to perform. Nevertheless, they induced victim organizations to enter contracts, received goods without paying for them, and absconded. The courts found that their conduct satisfied the elements of contract fraud.
2. Background
The Foshan company had operated normally since its establishment in 2004 but began sustaining losses in 2014 because of conditions in the steel market. Prosecutors alleged that from April through October 2015, the Pan brothers knew the company was insolvent yet fraudulently obtained more than RMB 53 million in property from 14 victim organizations and individuals.
2. Counsel’s Involvement and Work
After accepting the engagement, Guangdong FANA Chuanqiong Law Firm assigned a team including attorneys Pan Meiyu and Peng Xin, who undertook extensive defense work during the appeal and retrial:
Detailed file review and evidence analysis: The team spent nearly 1,000 hours reviewing the case files and examining dozens of volumes of evidence in detail.
In-depth review of bank transactions: Counsel independently checked transactions across 16 bank accounts and submitted a professional Bank Account Transaction Review Report. It identified nine key accounts that investigators had failed to obtain, leaving the destination of funds unclear.
Identifying defects in key evidence: Counsel discovered indications that sales contracts and delivery notes provided by the principal victim organization, “Foshan JC Company,” had been forged. The court ultimately excluded that evidence at the retrial.
Repeated client meetings and communication: Counsel met the client more than ten times, provided emotional support, and carefully verified the company’s production, operations, and handling of debts.
Legal research: The team conducted data-driven research into contract-fraud acquittals, sentencing patterns, and the assigned judges’ approaches, producing several research reports.
3. Principal Legal Arguments
At trial, counsel advanced the following central arguments to support treatment of the case as a civil commercial dispute rather than criminal fraud, or to reduce punishment:
No intent to unlawfully appropriate property: Counsel pointed out that before the case arose, Pan was still actively paying suppliers and employee wages and had retained lawyers to address debts and bankruptcy. This was active debt management, counsel argued, rather than absconding in the criminal-law sense.
Ordinary business activity rather than fraudulent acquisition: The Foshan company had stable, longstanding relationships with the victim organizations. The unpaid debts resulted from a business collapse caused by the global steel-market crash, with iron ore prices falling to a low, and banks calling in loans. Counsel characterized these as ordinary market risks.
Assets and liabilities had not been established: Counsel emphasized that the original trial lacked an asset valuation or audit. Before the incident, the company still had inventory worth more than RMB 20 million and machinery and equipment worth more than RMB 30 million. Counsel argued that it could not simply be deemed incapable of performance.
Reasonable uses of funds: Counsel showed that the great majority of funds went toward repayment of business-related private loans and payments for goods. There was no evidence of dissipation, unlawful appropriation, or diversion to other purposes.
Improper method of determining the offense amount: Counsel challenged reliance solely on victim statements and check amounts to determine the alleged loss. Negotiable instruments operate independently of their underlying transactions, counsel noted, and the actual transaction amounts sometimes differed from the face values.
4. Outcome and Changes
1. Initial Judgment
In March 2019, the court initially convicted Pan of contract fraud and sentenced him to life imprisonment with confiscation of all personal property.
2. Changes Achieved Through the Defense
On appeal, the court accepted counsel’s argument that the facts were unclear and the evidence insufficient, vacated the original judgment, and remanded the case for retrial. During the retrial, counsel secured exclusion of some false evidence and directed the court’s attention to objective factors, including market fluctuations.
3. Final Judgment
In August 2022, after lengthy proceedings, the court issued its final judgment. It upheld the classification as contract fraud but found the original sentences excessive and substantially reduced them:
Pan, originally sentenced to life imprisonment, received a fixed term of fifteen years.
Pan, originally sentenced to fifteen years of imprisonment, received a fixed term of twelve years.
Conclusion
Spanning five years, two first-instance trials, and two appeals, the case required nearly 1,300 hours of professional work by the legal team. Counsel succeeded in replacing a life sentence with a fixed term. The account presents this as demonstrating Guangdong FANA Chuanqiong Law Firm’s command of complex criminal cases and detailed evidence analysis, while using procedural fairness to give the client hope for a future beyond imprisonment.
Have a similar case?
Contact Us