Weekday hotline: 020-83550387 Holiday emergency: 18011704899/18011707162
Criminal Defense · Economic Crimes

Lenient Sentence for Logistics Company General Manager Charged with Waste Smuggling

Du (an anonymized name), a port logistics manager within a large imported-waste recycling group, was charged with waste smuggling after the company and its designated processing plants allegedly used borrowed permits to smuggle tens of thousands of metric tons of solid waste over seven years. Counsel developed a defense addressing both the case as a whole and Du’s individual responsibility: (1) the goods had not undergone the required waste-identification process; 80,853.142 metric tons covered by inspection certificates should be excluded; on-site customers had cooperative business relationships rather than merely borrowing approvals; and 38,944.631 metric tons imported before September 10, 2014, should be excluded because the earlier judicial interpretation did not deem the use of rented or borrowed permits to constitute smuggling; (2) Du’s successive positions as port manager, general manager of designated plant A, and general manager of a logistics company required an allocation of quantities by his periods of service, and he neither directly directed the unlawful activities nor held a position equivalent to the actual controllers. The court accepted the argument that his position and role were relatively less significant and imposed a lenient sentence of nine years’ imprisonment and a fine of RMB 200,000. Attorneys Peng Xin and Liu Zhuanying (external counsel) jointly represented him.

The English case materials below are translated from Chinese for reference only. If there is any difference in meaning, the Chinese originals prevail. Please contact FANA for clarification of the facts, legal terms or outcomes.

Case Details

I. Case Information

  • Case category: Litigation representation / criminal defense

  • Judgment date: June 2021

  • Defense counsel: Peng Xin (Guangdong FANA Chuanqiong Law Firm) and Liu Zhuanying (external counsel)

  • Law firm: Guangdong FANA Chuanqiong Law Firm

  • Charge: Waste smuggling

  • Outcome: nine years’ imprisonment and a fine of RMB 200,000

II. Case Background

This case concerned an alleged group offense involving the use of borrowed permits to smuggle solid waste whose importation was restricted by the state. Between 2011 and 2018, a trading company (the “group parent company”) provided permits held by designated processing plants within the group to unlicensed customers, including on-site customers, to declare imports of scrap metal, waste plastic, and other solid waste. Eight entities were involved, including designated plants A, C, D, E, B, F, and G, which held permits for the restricted import of solid waste usable as raw materials. The conduct spanned seven years and involved more than 10,000 containers. After the public security investigation concluded, the procuratorate prosecuted eight entities, including the group parent company, and 13 individual defendants for waste smuggling.

Defendant Du (an anonymized name) was an employee within the group parent company’s organization. He successively served as port manager, general manager of designated plant A, and general manager of ZC Logistics. These three periods involved different duties, employing entities, and lengths of service. After reviewing the file and appearing at two hearings, counsel systematically challenged both the total quantities attributed to the case and the allocation of individual responsibility.

III. Defense Work and Professional Contribution

1. Defense of the Overall Case: Four Grounds for Reducing the Quantities at Issue

After taking the case, counsel focused on systematically reducing the quantities at issue, a central sentencing factor, rather than pursuing what the account describes as an unrealistic claim that the entire case involved no criminal liability.

  • Missing waste-identification procedures: Counsel noted that the alleged imports extended for seven years from 2011, involved more than 10,000 containers and tens of thousands of import documents, yet investigators had not lawfully commissioned an authorized specialist appraisal institution to identify all the goods as waste. Because the goods had already been dismantled and sold and could no longer be examined, their nature had to be established through objective evidence in the record. The quantities at issue could not simply be accepted from the statistical conclusions in an appraisal opinion.

  • Exclusion of goods covered by inspection certificates: After closely reviewing the documents, counsel identified 1,475 shipments totaling 80,853.142 metric tons covered by Pre-Shipment Inspection Certificates of Conformity issued by the China Certification & Inspection Center. Counsel argued that these goods had passed inspection, were not waste prohibited from importation by the state, and should therefore be deducted from the smuggling quantities.

  • Questionable authenticity of documents seized by customs anti-smuggling officers: During examination of the evidence, counsel identified numerous documents whose originals and provenance could not be verified. Some photocopies were so distorted that their text was illegible, and some documents contained handwritten additions. Counsel argued that these defects compromised the evidence’s authenticity and made it unsuitable as a basis for calculating the quantities at issue.

  • On-site customers had cooperative relationships, not merely borrowed approvals: Drawing on statements by 11 defendants and documentary evidence counsel personally reviewed—including internal emails, customer quantity lists, and unloading-address records—counsel argued that the on-site customers had genuine commercial relationships with the designated plants. These included FX00, FX01, and DH00 at plant A; CZ00 at plant B; OP00 at plant E; and OK00 at plant C. The plants paid their processing costs, the operations complied with the plants’ environmental supervision requirements, and customs duties were paid. Counsel argued that these arrangements were not merely the borrowing of import approvals and should not be treated as smuggling. A preliminary reconciliation attributed 1,677 containers and 99,441.2889 metric tons to these six on-site customers.

2. Defense of the Overall Case: Applying the Earlier Interpretation Unless the Later One Is More Lenient

At the second hearing, attorney Peng Xin argued that the alleged waste smuggling from 2011 through 2018 spanned two judicial interpretations. Under Article 3 of the Provisions of the Supreme People’s Court and the Supreme People’s Procuratorate on the Temporal Effect of Judicial Interpretations, the earlier interpretation applies unless the later one is more lenient. Counsel argued that using another person’s rented, borrowed, or purchased permit before September 10, 2014, should not be treated as smuggling: the 2006 interpretation did not deem such conduct to constitute smuggling, whereas the 2014 interpretation added that rule.

  • Counsel calculated that 1,809 containers totaling 38,944.631 metric tons predated September 10, 2014, and argued that they should be excluded from the quantities in this case.

  • The account describes this argument as consistent with the principle of legality and the rules governing the application of judicial interpretations, substantially reducing the quantities at their source.

3. Individual Defense: Separating Du’s Three Positions and the Quantities Attributable to Him

Counsel used five key documents—a position-adjustment notice dated January 14, 2012; a master work-email list dated August 11, 2012; a travel notice dated November 19, 2015; a July 2016 personnel roster; and a corporate restructuring notice dated January 12, 2017—to establish Du’s three periods of employment within the group:

  • First period, 2011–December 2012: Port manager, initially at ports A and B, followed by a brief period in the group parent company’s international business department.

  • Second period, January 2013–December 2016: General manager of designated plant A.

  • Third period, January 2017 until the case arose: General manager of ZC Logistics within the group parent company.

Counsel argued that the quantities attributable to Du had to be determined using both his period of service and the entity where he worked. The quantities associated with all 13 defendants throughout their respective employment periods could not indiscriminately be assigned to him. This detailed approach applied the principle that punishment must be proportionate to the offense and individual culpability in a group crime.

4. Individual Defense: Secondary Participation and the “Human Firewall” Argument

On the disputed question of principal or secondary participation, attorney Peng Xin argued that Du was a secondary participant on four grounds:

  • Employment history: Before January 2017, he was a lower-level employee at the ports and designated plant, not a core member of the organization. After his transfer to ZC Logistics in January 2017, his monthly salary remained RMB 10,000; he received neither a pay increase corresponding to his general-manager title nor million-yuan profit distributions.

  • Meeting records: Du was largely absent from the notices and minutes of 13 group parent company meetings between June 2013 and December 2015. Counsel argued that this corroborated that he did not work at the parent company during that period and was not part of its core management.

  • Actual control: After 2017, the owner and actual controller continued to manage the departments directly through WeChat and telephone calls. Counsel characterized Du as a “human firewall” put in place by the owner to bear legal risks on the owner’s behalf.

Although the court did not ultimately recognize Du as a secondary participant, it accepted counsel’s argument that his position was relatively lower and his role relatively less significant than those of the actual controllers, and granted leniency.

5. Mitigation: Truthful Confession, Admission of Guilt and Acceptance of Punishment, and Remorse

  • Truthful confession: Du gave truthful, consistent, and stable statements after being brought into the case, satisfying the criteria for a truthful confession.

  • Admission of guilt and acceptance of punishment: During prosecutorial review, counsel requested application of the admission-of-guilt and acceptance-of-punishment procedure and communicated repeatedly with the prosecution. Counsel also submitted a written request at trial. Although disagreement with the proposed sentence prevented Du from signing the formal undertaking, counsel asked the court to give full sentencing weight to his sincere willingness to admit guilt and accept punishment.

  • Remorse: Du voluntarily returned unlawful proceeds and showed a positive attitude toward admitting guilt and accepting punishment.

IV. Outcome

The court accepted counsel’s argument that Du’s relatively lower position and less significant role compared with the actual controllers warranted leniency:

The court found that, although Du was a directly responsible manager, he participated in smuggling under the organization and direction of the company’s actual controllers, including Li (an anonymized name). His position was relatively lower and his role relatively less significant than theirs. He also admitted guilt, accepted punishment, and demonstrated remorse, making him eligible for leniency. The court further held that discretionary mitigation should reflect changes in his position and contribution to the smuggling activity as his management duties and powers changed during his work within the group parent company.

The court convicted Du of waste smuggling and sentenced him to nine years’ imprisonment and a fine of RMB 200,000. Among the 13 individual defendants, some received suspended sentences or shorter prison terms based on voluntary surrender, meritorious service, return of unlawful proceeds, or other factors. The account also states that four other individual defendants and all eight defendant entities were held criminally responsible.

V. Commentary and Broader Significance

This case illustrates a coordinated defense combining careful analysis of principal and secondary roles, individualized allocation of quantities, and application of the earlier judicial interpretation unless the later interpretation is more lenient. Attorneys Peng Xin and Liu Zhuanying (external counsel) used detailed legal analysis and close examination of the evidence to seek leniency based on quantities and relative position while accepting the legal characterization of the offense. The account describes the result as moving Du from potential treatment as a principal bearing heavier responsibility to a manager whose relatively lower position justified discretionary mitigation.

The defense approach offers three points of reference:

  • A systematic challenge to quantities: In a waste-smuggling case involving tens of thousands of metric tons, counsel sought reductions by examining waste-identification procedures, inspection certificates, the authenticity of anti-smuggling documents, the commercial relationships of on-site customers, and the temporal application of the 2014 interpretation, creating a comprehensive mitigation defense.

  • Individualized allocation of quantities: For a defendant who served in multiple positions and entities, counsel used position notices, email lists, personnel rosters, and restructuring notices to establish the relevant employment periods and entities, then separate the quantities attributable to him. This gave concrete effect to proportionality between punishment and individual culpability in a group offense.

  • Multiple grounds for distinguishing principal and secondary roles: Even though Du was not formally recognized as a secondary participant, the court accepted counsel’s analysis of his relatively lower position and lesser role, supported by his employment history, decision-making powers, meeting records, and the actual controllers’ conduct. This secured discretionary mitigation and shows the potential value of distinguishing degrees of responsibility even among defendants treated as principals.

As counsel stated in the defense submission: “Whether they were department managers earning a million yuan a year or lower-level employees earning RMB 3,000–5,000 a month, the 13 defendants in this case were merely instruments of the owner’s unlawful conduct and really should not bear such heavy punishment.” This theme ran through the defense and reflected Guangdong FANA Chuanqiong Law Firm’s stated approach of grounding advocacy in facts and law.

VI. Frequently Asked Questions

How can an individual seek leniency in a large corporate-group smuggling case?

Even a defendant treated as a responsible manager may seek leniency by: (1) showing a relatively lower position and lesser role than the actual controller through salary levels, reimbursement authority, meeting attendance, and similar evidence; (2) allocating quantities precisely by periods of employment; (3) establishing a truthful confession, admission of guilt and acceptance of punishment, and remorse; and (4) advocating application of the earlier judicial interpretation unless a later one is more lenient. Here, the court accepted counsel’s argument concerning Du’s relatively lower position and granted leniency.

When did importing waste using a rented, borrowed, or purchased permit become subject to the smuggling rule discussed in this case?

The source account explains that, under the principle of applying the earlier interpretation unless the later one is more lenient, the use of another person’s rented, borrowed, or purchased permit to import goods or articles subject to state import/export restrictions was deemed smuggling under the Interpretation of the Supreme People’s Court and the Supreme People’s Procuratorate on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in Handling Criminal Smuggling Cases, effective September 10, 2014. It states that earlier conduct should be assessed under the 2006 interpretation and does not constitute smuggling on that basis. The account credits counsel’s use of this principle with excluding substantial quantities.

Have a similar case?

Contact Us
Contact

Would you like to discuss your situation?

Speak with a Fana lawyer for professional guidance.

Contact Us